Pros & Cons of Heating Water in New Koi Pond

Advertise here koi

Page Summary:  Is it necessary to heat water in a new koipond? No unless you are one of the following...

  1. A serious koi show enthusiast intent on competing at the top Koi shows against fellow serious koi keepers. Without year round optimum temperatures you will never be able to compete for the top prizes at an important koi show
  2. You can afford the considerable capital and installation and running expenses to heat the koi pond water purely for the pleasure of it
  3. You are prepared to spend money on maintanance of the heating system.
  4. You are a very keen koi keeping enthusiast and live in an extremely cold climate with a prolonged winter and can afford the high heating costs

Heating Koi Pond Water.

However since we are talking of new koi ponds here and assuming the decision has been made that the water will be heated to maintain a constant temperature winter and summer then here are a few important considerations to take into account when designing the heated koi pond.

Get a competent chemical engineer to actually design the type of heater and it heating characteristics

Decide upon heating fuel to be used for heating and maintaining pond water temperatures.

Here again a chemical engineer is the right person to help you decide since it's a function not only of capital (installed) cost but also correct choice of fuel and arrangement to transfer heat from the fuel to the actual circulating pond water.

Getting the right answer is a function of many variables and remember the installation is for a lifetime.  

Sponsored Products...

Koi Food BradshawsEvery koi keeper buys food. All koi foods are not the same. Bradshaws Koi Food (and Wheatgerm) is as good as the best for quality and fantastic value for money in great sensible koi food packaging.

Interpet Koi Pond Test Kit If you want to test your pond water get a quality test kit from Interpet

Bradshaws Liner

25 year flexible pond liner guarantee

Breed your own koi with spawning brush.

After the fish have spawned put the spawning brush is placed in an area where adult koi cannot access it. Youll need a pond net

The design and control of a heated koi pond is complex by virtue of the significant differences in ambient temperatures and other prevailing weather conditions (eg wind will increase heating load as will falling snow and freezing ambient temperatures)

Heating koi pond water:

I don't intend to discuss pros and cons of heating water for the benefit of the koi. Rather I will focus on the engineering and safety aspects. This is also not intended to be a comprehensive discussion. Rather I will point out the most important considerations to be taken into account if you do wish to go ahead and install koi pond water heating.

*******
  1. The koi pond water heating system is rarely operating in a state for any significant length of time one since ambient temperatures change considerably. This means that instruments and control loops are required to maintain optimum pond water temperatures.
  2. With the help of the engineer decide if direct water heating (ie fuel is burned and it immediately heats the water) or indirect water heating (fuel is used to heat a heat transfer fluid which in turn heats the circulating water) is the preferred method of exchanging heat from fuel to recirculating pond water
  3. Decide upon fuel or method of heating the koi pond and extrapolate this into the future... energy costs are never constant and there is always a trade off between water heater running costs and capital costs for the pond water heating system. Remember if hydrocarbon fuels are chosen to heat the recirculating koi pond water then storage of fuel is required.
  4. Back up and safety systems... for example what will happen if the pond pump circulating system fails
  5. Where will you locate all the necessary equipment and control systems... once again safety plays a vital role in making this decision.
  6. Who will be responsible for this pond heating plant and especially so when you are away from home.

This list is not comprehensive but hopefully it makes the koi keeper acutely aware that heating a koi pond is not a DIY job. Heating pond water needs critically important equipment equipment and safety systems to be installed.

For a comprehensive website all about water heating and water heaters not just for ponds click the link

Articles about koi and fish pond care in winter

Pond Heaters. Heating koi ponds winter growth feeding benefits

Koi pond heating using gas electric in UK temperature control

Bringing fish and pond and water out of winter into spring

Koi goldfish pond covers over winter. How to look after pondfish

Over-wintering koi goldfish hibernation cold freezing water ice

Koi pond heating using gas electric in UK temperature control

Should I heat my new koi pond this winter. What temperature?

Temperature swings. Koi Goldfish Feeding & water temperature

To Feed or not to feed your pond fish or koi or goldfish

How Do I care For My Garden Fish Pond In Cold Winter

Frozen Koi Ponds & Fish Ponds. Ponds Freeze in Winter. Pond Care in Freezing Winter Weather

Interpet Koi Pond Test KitWhat the Does pH of Koi Pond Water Mean? Should I measure Pond pH